On newswork and journalistic identity construction. 

I’ve spent the past five years (give or take) trying to make sense of the ways journalists construct identity in news texts. This has included exploring reactions to WikiLeaks (my doctoral work [PDF]) as well as other research including with colleagues at Sheffield and  at the University of Groningen that has looked at how journalists position themselves in the context of crisis, in the context of digital change, and in comparison to other disruptions to an boundaries of the journalistic field.

My latest publication, in the journal Digital Journalismfocuses again on questions of journalistic identity and how identity is ‘performed’ in public-facing discourses within news texts, but adapts analytical approaches from structural narrative and literary analysis in an effort to make sense of some of these dynamics through a structural approach that explores semiotics and semantic constructions of identity and newswork. Here is the abstract:

Exploring constructions of journalistic identity in a digital age has been a lively area of scholarship as the field of digital journalism studies has grown. Yet despite many approaches to understanding digital change, key avenues for understanding changing constructions of identity remain underexplored. This paper addresses a conceptual void in research literature by employing semiotic and semantic approaches to analyse performances of journalistic identity in narratives of newswork facilitated by and focused on digital megaleaks. It seeks to aid understanding of the way narratives describe changing practices of newsgathering, and how journalists position themselves within these hybrid traditional/digital stories. Findings show news narratives reinforce the primacy of journalists within traditional boundaries of a journalistic field, and articulate a preferred imagination of journalistic identity. Methodologically, this paper shows how semantic and semiotic approaches lend themselves to studying narratives of newswork within journalistic metadiscourses to understand journalistic identity at the nexus of traditional and digital dynamics. The resultant portrait of journalistic identity channels a socio-historic, romantic notion of the journalist as “the shadowy figure always to be found on the edges of the century’s great events”, updated to accommodate modern, digital dynamics.

It’s an alternative way to build understanding of journalistic identity construction, for sure, and I think it opens new avenues for analysis and in its alternative approaches it, perhaps, points to new ways of sense making, particularly for complex news stories where multiple actors are in focus and when both the ‘news’ and the ‘journalism’ are part of the public conversation. I chose for this piece to apply analysis narratives of newswork in coverage of WikiLeaks and in coverage of the NSA leaks and Edward Snowden in elite newspapers (The New York Times, The Guardian, The Washington Post) to look at the performance of newswork when at its most prominent. Atypical stories, yes, but in their novelty these offer outsized opportunities for exploring the way journalists narrate their newswork and  construct journalistic identity in a way that invokes traditional dynamics amid uniquely digital dynamics. An Author Manuscript version can be found in via the publications link above, or  here.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s